When a KitchenAid refrigerator ice maker stops, the ice maker assembly is the most common fix in our records, often after it fails the harvest or water fill test. The next causes are the water valve or filter and a freezer that is not cold enough. KitchenAid also makes stand-alone undercounter ice machines, and those fail differently: pumps, control boards and the compressor. We have repaired more than 350 KitchenAid ice makers. In the 35 calls with detailed notes in our current job system, the ice maker assembly was replaced or needed in 13, cooling was the real cause in 5, the water supply in 4, and 4 were undercounter ice machines.
This guide is written from our own job records. We have fixed more than 350 KitchenAid ice makers; 35 of those calls, from 2024 to October 2026, are in our current job system with detailed notes, across Denver, Longmont, Boulder, Arvada, Lakewood, Broomfield, Greenwood Village, Littleton and the rest of the metro. The photos are from those calls.
What 35 detailed KitchenAid calls show
| What the technician noted | Calls | Typical part or fix |
|---|---|---|
| Ice maker assembly replaced or needed | 13 | W10884390, W11485529, W11658802, W10774430 |
| Cooling: iced evaporator, defrost control, fan, refrigerant leak | 5 | W10811365 board, W11249952 thermistor, WPW10128551 fan |
| Water supply: inlet valve, filter or filter head | 4 | W10853654, WPW10420083, W11567408 valves, W11346623 filter head |
| Undercounter ice machine: pump, control board, compressor | 4 | W11034363 control board, circulation pump |
| Door wiring, ice door, drain | 3 | W11130210 ice door, wiring repair, drain cleaning |
Notes are short and one call can fall in more than one row, so these are minimums. The ice maker we install most often in KitchenAid refrigerators is W10884390: it shows up on three of our tickets, two in Denver and one in Lafayette.
When the ice maker assembly has failed

Most KitchenAid refrigerators have a service mode with an ice maker harvest test and a water fill test. When the ice maker fails, it usually stops partway through the harvest test, and often there is no error code at all. In Lakewood the owner of a KRMF706EBS05 ran the diagnostics himself: no ice maker code, but the harvest test would not complete. The ice maker (W11485529) was replaced. In Brighton the ice maker showed an E5 code and was replaced (W11658802).


A new ice maker alone does not always fix it. In Highlands Ranch the owner of a KRSF505 side-by-side had already replaced the ice maker and the water valves himself; it worked for a while and then stopped again. When that happens, the cause is usually cooling, a control or wiring fault, not the ice maker. In Arvada a side-by-side needed a door wiring repair.
When the freezer is not cold enough

An ice maker needs a freezer at about 0°F. On KitchenAid we found:
- Ice on the evaporator. In Boulder the evaporator was covered in ice and was not giving enough cooling to make ice.
- A defrost control fault. In Centennial the freezer was warm and the fan was noisy; during a forced defrost the control board did not send power to the heater. The board (W10811365) and a thermistor (W11249952) were the parts.
- A refrigerant leak. In Lone Tree the ice maker was making ice too slowly; the cause was a refrigerant leak at the evaporator (W11492867).
- A fan and damper. In Lafayette the evaporator fan, the damper and the ice maker were on the parts list.

If the fridge or the freezer is also warmer than usual, see our guide to Whirlpool refrigerators not cooling: KitchenAid refrigerators are built by Whirlpool and share most of the same parts.
When water does not reach the ice maker
If the ice maker does not fill, check the water supply. In Golden the ice maker was not filling and the filter and filter head (W11346623) were replaced. Water valves were replaced in Denver (WPW10420083), Greenwood Village (W10853654) and Broomfield (W11567408). On one Denver call a plumber was needed first.
KitchenAid undercounter ice machines

A KitchenAid undercounter ice machine is a separate appliance with its own compressor, water pump and control board. It makes clear ice on a cold plate and needs a working drain. The failures we see:
- Control board. In Arvada the control board (W11034363) was replaced on two calls; on one of them the circulation pump was not running.
- Water pump. In Longmont a small KitchenAid ice maker needed a new circulation pump.
- Compressor. In Erie an ice machine that was making very little ice had a compressor problem.

For these machines, cleaning and descaling matter: hard water and scale slow ice production. See our ice machine repair page.
Video: KitchenAid ice maker not working
Video by AppliancePartsPros
What we see on Denver calls
- On our 35 detailed KitchenAid ice maker calls, the ice maker assembly was replaced or needed in 13 (W10884390, W11485529, W11658802, W10774430).
- Cooling problems (iced evaporator, defrost control, fan, refrigerant leak): 5 calls. Water supply (inlet valve, filter or filter head): 4 calls.
Don’t want to do it yourself? Call 720-230-1229.
Safe checks before you call
- Make sure the ice maker is turned on in the control panel and the bin is seated.
- Check the freezer temperature: about 0°F is right; above 10°F ice production slows down or stops.
- Test the water dispenser. No water there either points to the valve, the filter or the supply line.
- Replace a filter older than six months and make sure it is fully seated.
- Look for ice on the back wall of the freezer or around the ice maker.
- For an undercounter ice machine, check that the drain is clear and the unit is not in a cleaning cycle.
- Write down the model number from the label inside the fridge, such as KRMF706EBS05, KRSF505 or KFIS29PBMS00.
What it costs
On our price list an ice maker assembly starts from $259 for labor, a defrost repair from $179, and sealed-system work from $479, with parts quoted separately. The home diagnostic visit is from $59 and is credited toward the repair. See our prices.
When to call a technician
- The ice maker fails the harvest or fill test, or shows an error code.
- A new ice maker works for a while and then stops again.
- Ice builds up on the freezer wall or the freezer is warm.
- An undercounter ice machine stops making ice, leaks or keeps running.
We repair KitchenAid ice makers, refrigerators and undercounter ice machines across 52 Denver-area cities. See KitchenAid refrigerator repair, KitchenAid refrigerator error codes and our general guide to ice makers not making ice. For other brands, see Whirlpool, GE, Samsung and LG.
How to prevent this
Many of these breakdowns start with maintenance that was skipped. These guides show what to check, how often, and what happens if you don't:
Frequently asked questions
Why is my KitchenAid ice maker not making ice but there is no error code?
That is common. In our records the ice maker often failed the harvest test without any code. Check the freezer temperature and the water supply, then have the ice maker tested.
What does E5 mean on a KitchenAid ice maker?
On the KitchenAid where we saw E5, it pointed to the ice maker, and the ice maker assembly was replaced. Codes vary by model, so check your manual.
Why did my new KitchenAid ice maker stop working again?
If the ice maker was replaced and stopped again, the cause is usually elsewhere: ice on the evaporator, a defrost or control fault, door wiring, or the water supply.
Can you repair a KitchenAid undercounter ice machine?
Yes. We repair control boards, pumps, compressors and drain problems on KitchenAid undercounter ice machines.
Is it worth repairing a KitchenAid ice maker?
Usually yes. An ice maker, a water valve or a board is a contained repair, and KitchenAid refrigerators are worth keeping running.